Volume VI / Year 2025
By Audrey Bertin
Published on Aug 05, 2025 • DOI: 10.38105/spr.wyzhrvzk65

Scientific innovation continues to shape society in profound ways, but it also raises complex ethical questions. This year, the MIT Science Policy Review introduces our first themed volume: Ethics in Innovation. The issue explores how scientific developments from a variety of fields, from biotechnology to nuclear power to artificial intelligence, can present both opportunities and risks, and how policy can be used to mitigate and manage these. By bringing ethics to the forefront, this volume encourages thoughtful examination of how innovation aligns with societal values and long-term well-being.

PDF
MITSPR-v6-191618006001-Editors-Note.pdf
Size: 246 KB

Highlights

  • Scientific advancements are sometimes driven by commercial interests that may conflict with broader societal well-being.
  • Ethical conduct in science can be undermined by systemic pressures like speed, prestige, and lack of formal ethics training, and policy is key in maintaining ethics in place.
  • This volume explores ethical challenges in emerging technologies through a new thematic focus: Ethics in Innovation, our first ever themed release.

Although scientific progress is often made by only a select number of individuals, everyone has a right to benefit from these advancements. This concept has been a societal tenet for decades, enshrined in Article 27 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights: “Everyone has the right freely to participate in the cultural life of the community, to enjoy the arts, and to share in scientific advancement and its benefits” [1].

While simple in concept, achieving universal benefits from scientific advancement is a Sisyphean task. Human rights are often at odds with the self-interest of those promoting new technologies.

Is scientific advancement always a good thing?

Consider the recent development of Generative AI. Over the past several years, Generative AI has grown from something that very few–bar a small subset of computer science researchers–were familiar with to what is now a multi-billion dollar industry and projected to grow exponentially over the next decade [2].

With such large sums of money hanging in the balance, companies are incentivized to develop advancements quickly–rather than thoughtfully and safely–or risk losing their market share. Nearly every company seems to be integrating AI into their products, often without regard for whether this addition delivers any tangible value to users.

For example, Google’s search engine now provides an AI summary as the first result on all searches [3]. Of course, prior to this change, the existing system was more than adequate—it gave an effective ranking of results that in most cases provided the user exactly what they were looking for–but the addition of AI provides, at the very least, the illusion of assisting the user.

The challenge with this, though, is–at what cost? This advancement appears on a surface level to improve productivity—if they can trust the AI result and no longer need to peruse multiple pages on a quest to find answers, users can see dramatic time savings. When looking deeper, however, things become murkier. Anecdotally, Google Search AI summaries are often inaccurate. They can provide incorrect information in a way that comes across as trustworthy (a concept called “hallucination”) or over-simplify complex topics, leaving out key details. Users looking to save time or obtain a simple answer may regard this summary as fact rather than invest the time to read any of the suggested search results in full.

Is this scientific advancement truly benefitting society? As someone who was raised with the value of always conducting my own research and making informed decisions, I would argue that it may not be. Providing shortcuts that allow us to disengage our brains poses the risk of damaging the human ability to think critically and creatively. Although we may be saving time in the moment, we are not necessarily better off long term. If users perceive the AI as beneficial, though, it is in Google’s self interest to continue to develop that technology, regardless of whether perception matches reality.

Conflicting interests like this are pervasive in scientific development, affecting not just companies but also individual scientists, who can face pressure to publish quickly even when their work does not meet the standards of rigor that should be expected in novel research. Even the most highly regarded scientists are not immune to this. Consider 2018 Nobel Prize winning chemistry researcher Frances Arnold, who retracted a 2019 Science paper she had co-authored on the principle that the results were not reproducible and thus should not be trusted [4]. In a note published to Twitter, Arnold stated that: “I apologize to all. I was a bit busy when this was submitted and did not do my job well” [5].

Rushing can certainly lead to less-than-ideal outcomes, but this of course is just one concern. There is of course also the danger of scientific advancements being co-opted for nefarious purposes. It is easy to imagine how CRISPR, a gene-editing technology, could be used for ethnic cleansing, or how new computer technology could be used to create deepfakes that intentionally spread misinformation.

The importance of policy

This is, of course, where policy comes into the picture. Technology is not inherently good or evil–the outcomes of advancement rely entirely on how, where, and for what purpose any given technology is applied. When AI is used to enhance Google Search, the effects might be counter-productive, but AI applied to the goal of detecting rare cancers can be a life-saving innovation.

Through regulation, we can create safeguards to reduce the risk of harm, but there is no such thing as a perfect solution. Every scientific advancement comes with a complex set of ethical considerations and tradeoffs.

These ethical considerations are of critical importance to society, but are often overlooked. As a society, we regularly work to produce ethical frameworks and codes of conduct, but these efforts are often more performative–or, even if well-intentioned, fruitless–than they are effective. As Jane Johnson writes in a 2010 publication:

“one issue with respect to some codes of conduct and ethics is that although they may supply aspirations and even appropriate rules for behaviour, individuals may not possess the practical knowhow or skills to apply them. Thus, even the most well-conceived, well-written and comprehensive codes may not foster ethical conduct if the individuals to whom they are meant to apply do not understand how to follow them, or have not been involved in the process of developing them” [6].

Part of the challenge is a lack of exposure to ethics in scientific curricula. Anecdotally, most curricula across the sciences offer some sort of opportunity to study ethics, but this offering is typically quite limited–just one or two courses–and rarely mandatory. When ethics are not explicitly interwoven into learning and research processes, it can be easy to gain only a surface level understanding or avoid ethical discussions altogether.

Introducing our theme

At The MIT Science Policy Review, our goal is to take an objective lens when considering policy–we do not publish opinions nor make policy recommendations, but instead attempt to clarify policy issues and the strengths and weaknesses of potential policy approaches so that they can be considered holistically. However, we do take a firm stance on several core values in our published work, including:

  • Ease of access—Our articles should remain free and easily available to all.
  • Accessibility—Almost anyone should be able to read one of our pieces and glean some understanding, regardless of their previous knowledge in the subject.
  • Education—Our goal is to educate policymakers and the general public on cutting edge topics in science research and their intersections with policy, as well as to provide an opportunity for students from a hard science background to gain experience in writing about policy.

Although ethics is not explicitly part of this list, it is critical to the work we do as scientists and policy experts, especially in a time where the U.S. government appears to be trying to remove the type of regulations that help ensure safe development and research. This year we decided that it was important to highlight in our work, to require both authors and readers to interact with these concepts and consider them in their work.

Traditionally, our publication has remained theme-less. We accept articles from a wide variety of topics with little in common beyond a shared focus on policy. In Volume VI, we have decided to explore something different with our first ever thematic volume: Ethics in Innovation. For this volume, all authors were asked to incorporate a discussion of ethics into their work in some capacity.

This volume, we look at ethical issues in a wide variety of fields and emerging technologies, from the dangers of emerging biotechnologies and their potential applications in bioterrorism to questions around the validity of citizen science.

Conclusion

Ethical considerations are not a peripheral concern in scientific advancement—they are foundational. As innovation accelerates, it becomes increasingly important for scientists, companies, and policymakers to think critically about the consequences of new technologies and ensure that ethics is embedded in the development process. This volume of MIT Science Policy Review aims to spotlight the many ways ethics shapes, challenges, and ultimately strengthens innovation across disciplines.

Acknowledgments

I would like to thank our executive and associate editors for their many hours of work editing for this volume, as well as our authors for pushing through despite the many challenges that have faced the U.S. scientific research world in the past year. A special thank you to last year’s Editor-in-Chief, Jenny Cascino, for her guidance and support in navigating the many challenges of leading a journal, and to my deputy Editors-in-Chief, Natalie Gehred and Dylan McCormick, for their invaluable help managing the team this year.


Citation: Bertin, A. Ethics in innovation: A guiding principle for science and science policy. MIT Science Policy Review 6, 1-3 (2025). https://doi.org/10.38105/spr.wyzhrvzk65.
References:
  1. United Nations General Assembly. Universal declaration of human rights, vol. 3381 (Department of State, United States of America, 1949).
  2. Generative AI to become a $1.3 trillion market by 2032, research finds (2023). Online: Bloomberg Press Release.
  3. Reid, L. Generative AI in Search: Let Google do the searching for you (2024). Online: Google Blog.
  4. Cho, I., Zhi-Zhun, J. & Arnold, F. H. Retraction. Science 367, 155–155 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aba6100.
  5. Nobel Prize-winning scientist Frances Arnold retracts paper (2020). BBC News.
  6. Johnson, J. Teaching ethics to science students: Challenges and a strategy. In Education and ethics in the Life Sciences: Strengthening the prohibition of biological weapons, 197–213 (ANU E Press, 2010).
This MIT Science Policy Review article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.

This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description.