MIT Science Policy Review • Volume 5 (2024)
By Simar Kaur Mattewal and Ritika Sethi
Published: August 27, 2024  |  Edited by: Natalie D. Gehred  |  DOI Link: 10.38105/spr.7t8f2bk6b8

MIT Science Policy Review spoke with Dr. Latif Nasser and Lulu Miller, the hosts of Radiolab, to understand how podcasts can be used to tell scientific stories. Radiolab, launched in 2002, is an investigative podcast that covers a diverse range of topics, from science to politics to philosophy. Known for its versatility, Radiolab excels in storytelling, and has been recognized by multiple prestigious awards like the Peabody Award, People’s Choice Podcast Awards, and many more. Miller and Nasser have been involved in the creation of Radiolab episodes in multiple capacities: reporting, producing, and since 2020, hosting.

Lulu Miller is a Peabody Award-winning science journalist, and the author of the international bestseller, Why Fish Don’t Exist. Her written work has been published in The New Yorker, The Paris Review, VQR, and beyond. She is also the creator of the podcast Terrestrials and co-creator of Invisibilia. She has won honors from the National Academy of Sciences and the Associated Press, among others.

Dr. Latif Nasser has a PhD in History of Science from Harvard University and has reported stories on everything from snowflake photography to medieval robots. Beyond Radiolab, he has hosted the mini-series The Other Latif, and the Netflix documentary series, Connected.

In this interview, Miller and Nasser discuss the intricacies of podcasting as a medium of communication and offer insights into how scientists can use storytelling to effectively communicate complex scientific ideas to a broad audience.

PDF

Read Full Interview Report

File Size: 2 MB (191618005030.pdf)

Download PDF

Science Policy Review: What experiences led you to podcasting? What do you love the most about your job as hosts of Radiolab?

Lulu Miller: I didn’t really like radio growing up, but there was something that just hit right as I graduated college. I felt like the world was expanding and I was getting smaller. Uncertain about what was next, I stumbled upon This American Life and Radiolab in its early days. These shows featured audio with music and soundscapes, much like the sort of podcasts you hear today. I felt a very powerful urge to reside in these spaces, especially Radiolab where podcasters would ask philosophical, existential and often unanswerable questions to scientists. These scientists, typically cautious, enjoyed being nudged out of their comfort zone. The blend of hard science and profound, unanswerable questions, mixed with music, felt like tapping the edge of what’s known. This also resonates with one of our taglines, “taking you past the edge of what you think you know.”

Listening to people to make sense of what’s known—but also being open and not believing that the world is entirely figured out—gives me a warm yet thrilling feeling. That’s what drew me in and sustains me. Whenever I feel frustrated with the world and its certainties, these stories remind me that there’s a little more we don’t know. I’m just desperately hungry for this sense of wonder and exploration.

Dr. Latif Nasser: In grad school, I studied the history of science. I liked science and storytelling a lot. I would often get interested in random topics, research them, and write them up. Whenever I would learn something new, I would just get excited and have this urge to tell people about the things I learned. I would also submit my writings to academic journals but they were usually rejected as they would not fit the conventional format. This left me wondering what to do with my passion for sharing intriguing stories. Around that time, I discovered Radiolab and it felt like all of the sudden, I found a space that I didn’t realize existed, where you can geek out about topics and tell compelling stories. Despite having no audio production, journalism, or reporting experience, I reached out to the executive producer of Radiolab. I pitched a bunch of ideas, all of which she rejected, but [she] encouraged me to send more. Eventually, one of my ideas was accepted and I was tasked to report it. Since I was new, she guided me through the process. I also worked for the Boston Globe where a kind editor mentored me and explained how journalism worked. I was doing this throughout grad school and by the time it ended, it was clear that storytelling and being a journalist were a better fit for me than the academic route. Neither [Lulu nor I] thought that one day we would be the hosts of a show. In fact, when we started, podcasting wasn’t even considered a real job. Back then, the attitude [towards podcasting] was, "This isn’t good enough for the radio, so let’s just put it on the internet and see if anyone listens." Our journey here was really about following what felt good and benefitting from the kindness of people who took us under their wings. Their mentorship and support played a crucial role in where we are now. This job constantly gives me the thrilling moment of discovering something new and wanting to shout it from the rooftops, sharing that excitement with everyone. That endless curiosity drives me, and making it my daily work is what I absolutely love about what we do.

SPR: You have both been involved in various aspects of Radiolab’s production over the years. What role do you most identify with, professionally?

Miller: I see myself as a journalist. When we both started, podcasts were just becoming a thing, but I’ve always had a deep affection for terrestrial radio—the kind you listen to while driving, just turning it on to see what’s playing and so I think of myself as a radio journalist.

Nasser: I tend to identify more as a professional nerd. While journalism is a big part of what we do, working for New York Public Radio (WNYC), we’re not the typical reporters attending press scrums. Our work reminds me a lot of my grad school days but with more variety. In academia, your focus gets funneled narrower and narrower, but we’re fortunate to be professional generalists. We dive deep into one topic today and explore something entirely different tomorrow. It feels like we hit the jackpot—we are professional nerds and we get to nerd out about different things every day.

SPR: What is your role as the hosts of Radiolab?

Nasser: It’s interesting because we serve as the "middle people" in this process. On one side, we’re trying to bring the most honest and compelling story out of the reporter, but on the other side we are also the ambassadors for the listeners. We’re the ones who get to ask the questions that listeners might be having at that moment, or perhaps even questions they didn’t realize they wanted answered until we ask them. Our role is to advocate for the audience and bridge gaps between the reporter’s detailed journey and the listener’s curiosity and make information more accessible to people by asking the questions that they would ask if they had the opportunity to be there, too.

Miller: We both are reporters at heart and so we like to dive into our own pieces. But as hosts, our main role is to be generous and playful—yet skeptical—conversational partners. Reporters go out, do extensive research, read numerous papers, and talk to people for hours, gathering all sorts of nuances and complex information. As hosts of a podcast, it is our responsibility to meet them with fresh eyes. We come in without much prior knowledge, almost like blank slates with excitement. It is as if these reporters, brimming with facts, complex information, and confusion, have come from an odyssey and are going to share their knowledge with us. I think we’re a little more alive than just a sounding board; our job is to get the most gripping—yet natural, authentic, and real—narrative from the reporter. We avoid overly showy or fake-sounding tales and stay away from fake entertainment. We push the conversation towards authenticity, ensuring the story feels real and compelling. So I would describe our job as conversational partners.

SPR: As the mediator between the audience and the story, how do you approach sensitive topics and ask uncomfortable questions?

Nasser: It’s like when you’re in school, and you think, "I’m gonna raise my hand and ask the question, because I know I’m not the only one who has this question." If I don’t ask, it would be a missed opportunity: I wouldn’t get to explore emotional depths with this person. And there are times when it’s delicate, and times when you ask a question and reconsider, but that’s literally my job—I’ve got to muscle through the awkwardness and ask that question! And I really work hard to make it as sensitive as I can, but you have to ask the question because that’s the job.

SPR: Could you describe the process of finding new stories?

Miller: At Radiolab, we have a very collaborative pitch process. About once a month the team meets to present story ideas, which can range from fresh thoughts to pitches that have been in development for months, depending on the story and the person. Everyone has different ways; for me, nothing spurs new story ideas better than reporting itself. For example, you might be interviewing someone about the brain’s ability to regenerate, and stumble upon an obscure study of transplanting memories between rats, leading the story in a completely new direction. I think this process—where you are investigating one thing and come across so many other topics in its periphery that you could’ve never thought of yourself—is invaluable.

During our pitch meetings, each idea gets about 15 minutes of discussion, where the team brainstorms different angles, shares thoughts on what excites them, and considers various aspects of the pitch. We then vote based on whether the story is intriguing, whether it leads to unexpected voices, whether it meets our criteria, etc. Then we decide which story we want to move forward with as a team.

SPR: Where in the process, from pitch meeting to the final product, is the audience considered, and whom do you identify as your audience?

Miller: We’re almost always thinking about the audience. You think about them in the pitch, where you’re trying to hook someone and considering why they should care about this random research, and then you think about them throughout the series of drafts, and this continues over and over through editing. We don’t want science to feel boring. We want our audience to be gripped into a narrative, and then let it smash into science when they don’t even see it coming. So while crafting a piece we have to think: Where are they going to be bored or riveted? Where can we give them a little more space? We have to consider that the audience is busy and can listen to a million other things. We’re just always thinking about them. We waste days not to waste your seconds; we want every second of it to be good, and that’s another reason it takes so long.

Nasser: Sometimes we do episodes for adults, sometimes we want them to be kid-friendly, but to be honest, I don’t really think about those a lot. I feel like we play to our colleagues. In the pitch, that’s our audience, so we’re thinking more about playing to each other. There are blind spots with that approach, and in some cases we have people come in for sensitivity listens. Though, a lot of times, we’re trying to entertain ourselves, writing to each other. So we’re not trying to please some abstract audience. We’re just trying to make each other laugh or cry, and we do that!

Miller: Our audience is also fairly diverse. It is a nice range of ages and sexes and races. For me, I’m trying to hook two people. One is the Midwestern soccer mom (not because suddenly I have turned into one), who’s maybe not even an NPR listener, and she’s driving along, busy. People have written her off as not being a deep thinker, but she’s flipping through the radio trying to get some good music and she hears some question or irreverent tale, and she wants to linger. She wants a moment of the world expanding. Second is a high schooler, with their peak cognitive powers. They might not have context and you would have to give them a quick background to engage them. But once they’re in, they can think, they can debate and they don’t want to be talked down to. Their bar is high! I want to hook people who might not think that Radiolab is for them. I don’t want them to be alienated. I want to invite them and show that there’s something for them too.

SPR: How do you consider the dwindling attention spans of the audience?

Miller: What true crime is doing right is [recognizing] that suspense keeps people in, even people without good attention spans. So my personal philosophy is that, if you can do work up top and use the beginning to hook someone, then they’ll stay and listen through some really slow-paced stuff. Dangle a question, make the question "hook-y", and sneak the wonder in.

Nasser: And make it a question that once you hear you can’t leave, Because you need to hear the answer. As a grad student, I used to go to a talk everyday, and a professor of mine said he didn’t like them. He said, “They always tell you the answer, but they never tell you the question. They just assume that you know the question.” And I think that is so true in academic circles, that people start with questions that fit the thing they wanted to tell you. Don’t back-engineer a fake question. Root it in a genuine question that feels high-stakes, personal, emotional, has a lot of money riding on it, or is connected to the big questions of the universe.

Miller: And we don’t always get it at the beginning. That’s why we have collaboration with editors and people listening. We all help each other get there.

SPR: From your answers, it is evident that you value your Radiolab team. What would you say makes the Radiolab team unique?

Nasser: I would say they’re all totally different. It’s a heterogeneous group of people that have different backgrounds and different interests. What they all have in common is a real commitment to the form. They like audio and they think in audio terms. They’re deep, inquisitive people, so if you ask a question, or raise something, they’re not going to let you get away with it. They care about fundamental things like truth and the story and hold us to it.

Miller: Everyone on our team has a degree of creative intensity where they can carry out their own vision. Everyone brings their style to the table. For example, one of our editors doesn’t want our endings to be too simple or tied with a bow. Another editor always wants to tuck in some play and she’ll do it for a piece she’s voicing but also for any other piece. We give notes on pieces we’re not even on. It is so collaborative, it’s so generous, it’s so creatively generous. When you’re writing, you’re mostly alone. Maybe your editor gives you some notes, but you have to solve your problems alone. But here at Radiolab, there is just this team of pranksters and geniuses who want to help solve the problem. By the end, it’s nobody’s story and is everybody’s story. What is unique is that we have a team of the most brilliant, creative, and playful minds who are going to bat for whatever idea you want to birth into the world.

Nasser: It’s magical. We’re like a family and it’s dysfunctional, and we all have issues, but we’re pretty lucky. It’s like we share one brain and we get to finish each other’s sentences, and it’s great!

SPR: How would you describe the roles that fact-checking or sound design play in the creation of the narratives that Radiolab is known for?

Miller: I love how fact-checking and sound design play with each other. We fact-check every sentence. It is so important that we report on what’s real, so even if we want to paint a picture of something more magical or exciting, our fact-checker is there to rein us in and not over-promise what we know. With the fractured realities we get through the internet, it is harder and harder to know what’s real. One thing we really care about is that our stories are objectively true. We also care about beauty, and we care about playing, and we’re not trying to give you something boring, but fact-checking is a counterweight. It’s the anchor that lets us just play and infuse moments with beauty. One of the heartbeats of the show is that the only creative constraint is that the show is fact-based and true.

Nasser: To add to what Lulu said, we value trust. If you miss one little thing, it can erode trust. You can lose somebody over one tiny detail. An example that connects the sound design and fact-checking is a story I did called "Nukes" [9]. The story had a Vietnam veteran who was a helicopter rescue guy, and so we were using the audio of a helicopter. Our sound designer fact-checked what helicopter that audio came from and if that helicopter was in use in Vietnam at that time. For him, it was important that someone who was a Vietnam veteran, who may know what helicopters during that time sounded like, know that we put in the work, because otherwise they’re not going to trust us on anything. If we’re lying about an audio clip, then what else are we lying about? Trust is such a valuable thing and we’re playing the long game. The show has been around for 20 years and we want to be around a long time. We don’t want to abuse that trust and we take it really seriously.

Miller: Sound design does a couple of things. It could help the experiment come to life. For example, if we are reporting on an experiment about fear and memory formation where a rat remembers how to run a maze after being shocked, you can add audio to help the listener picture the rat. If you let the experiment be visual, and invite the listener into the scientific process—into how we come to our knowledge, how we design experiments—that empowers them to take from it what they want to take, instead of just scientists concluding this thing about fear and memory. Sound design can also help you walk into the question and add drama to what you want to know. It’s really good at helping with emotion, leaving room to bask in something really profound, and letting a person contemplate their thoughts about how this wrinkle of complexity changes their own life or what questions it leads them to. For me, what sound design does is take something that a lot of people dismiss as dry science and make it feel both emotional and carnal.

Nasser: Fact-checking and sound design are like brain and heart. [They’re] different ways to engage: sometimes they go in the same direction, and sometimes in opposite directions in a story, but you want both of them to be fully on board and you want someone to feel like they can just fall into it and trust us and that there are no red flags popping up intellectually or emotionally along the way.

SPR: Does the kind of science that you can communicate change with the medium, especially since podcasts lack visual cues?

Nasser: I don’t think that the science changes. Depending on your audience, the level of simplicity goes up or down. Certain stories are much more suitable to be visual stories that you just can’t really tell in audio, and vice versa. Perhaps, some stories about things that are not visible, like maybe gravitational waves, would be better in audio.

Miller: I think what audio gives you is freedom from your visual judgments. People give out so much information with their facial expressions and sometimes there’s dignity in not having to encounter someone’s physicality, because we’re wired to be judgmental. When we’re piecing together stories, everything from the room to your hair becomes a part of the story. I do think there are certain things like an optical illusion where getting to actually see it might be beautiful, but audio gets the leg up, or it’s easier to do it in audio, because you can guide people’s focus better. You can choose how you’re describing it.

Nasser: I tried to do a story where I told the audience to hold an image in their head and then take this other totally different image and put them together. I think in general, you can tell any story in any form and it works. People are looking for the same things: character, surprise, and to learn something new. But, I think there are certain stories that lend themselves to one or another medium.

SPR: What advice do you have for budding podcasters or those considering entering this profession, even as a side hustle?

Miller: I always think about it in terms of a three-pronged approach. First, get involved with an existing institution. If you’re really interested in podcasting, start by looking for community podcasts, local radio shows, or small-scale podcasts that already exist. Try to collaborate or intern with them to gain experience and learn from others. Even if there isn’t a direct opportunity, exploring and networking can help you get your foot in the door.

Second, experiment and create your own content. Having at least one creative partner can be incredibly helpful. This partner doesn’t need to be from your field—just someone who inspires you. It could be a music lover who wants to edit with you, or a fellow scientist with whom you can learn the editing process together. Set deadlines for each other and aim to produce a set number of episodes, even if no one hears them. The key is to practice and refine your skills together.

And third, seek education. Enroll in journalism, documentary, audio, or writing classes. These can be a part of formal education or continuing education programs. Look for workshops, such as those offered by Transom [10] or Center for Documentary Studies [11], which can range from multi-month programs to weekend workshops. Many organizations also offer free resources, essays, and short workshops online. Learn as much as you can.

Nasser: I’d offer somewhat unconventional advice, specifically to a STEM Ph.D. student who wants to start with podcasting. I would suggest they try new things, like reading about theater and dramaturgy, and learning how to tell a story. While fundamentals like character development, dramatization, plot structure, and pacing may seem basic, mastering these elements is like having cheat codes to get people interested, regardless of the topic you’re talking about or the field you’re in. There’s so much fascinating stuff to talk about, and if you can do it in this certain way, in a certain pattern, in a certain form that people tend to be more interested in, you’ll meet your audience much better.

SPR: As scientists, we often use jargon and complex terms when discussing science with the general public, which can make it hard for them to understand. What strategies can we use to make science more accessible and understandable to everyone?

Nasser: Find a child, maybe a high schooler, who doesn’t know or care about your scientific terms and explain your topic to them; try to get them excited about it. These terms can often be crutches that we should try to leave behind when talking to non-specific audiences. Reverse-engineer yourself!

Miller: Yeah, choose someone who’s willing to listen, a child, a friend outside of science, or a parent. Notice how you talk and observe what parts of your explanation resonate with them. Try figuring out the beats, the little tricks that make your story sound interesting and clear. Trust those beats of the story and see where the listener actually leans in. Notice where their fascination piques because it might be different from your own. And don’t put all your eggs in one basket: test your theory with multiple listeners and see what consistently works well. That’s definitely something I do when I’m preparing a story. So, take your explanation out for a stroll!


Acknowledgments: The authors would like to thank the Science Policy Review and Radiolab teams for their roles in bringing together this piece.

Citation

Mattewal, S.K. and Sethi, R. Podcasts as tools for science communication. MIT Science Policy Review 5, 160-165 (2024). https://doi.org/10.38105/spr.7t8f2bk6b8.

References

  1. [1] Radiolab (2024). Link
  2. [2] Peabody Awards (2010). Link
  3. [3] Miller, L. Why Fish Don’t Exist (Simon & Schuster, 2021).
  4. [4] Radiolab. Terrestrials (2010). Link
  5. [5] NPR. Invisibilia. Link
  6. [6] Radiolab. Lulu Miller: Co-host, Radiolab. Link
  7. [7] Radiolab. The other Latif (2020). Link
  8. [8] Netflix. Connected (2020). Link
  9. [9] Radiolab. Nukes (2017). Link
  10. [10] Transom. A showcase and workshop for new public radio. Link
  11. [11] Duke Center for Documentary Studies. Link

This MIT Science Policy Review article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description. This is an example biographical description.