Science Policy Review: How do academics and policymakers currently interact, if at all, and what do you see as the value of this interaction?
Kate Burns: We see a few degrees of interaction here and now. One is collaboration on a per-project or per-grant basis, prompted by a one-time funding opportunity emphasizing partnership, or someone in the city needing to tap academics into a single project. But my work focuses on another kind of collaboration—transformational alliances—which go in perpetuity. These aren’t bound to any one-off project or grant opportunity but comprise regular meetings in which representatives from both sides discuss how they can support each other down the road. MetroLab was started in 2015 as the national consortium for these local transformational alliances, the child of the Obama White House’s "Smart Cities" initiative [2]. The mission was pursued immediately by university provosts, presidents, mayors, and city councils, who sought to work together on emerging technology issues. Universities are technically creatures of the state, but typically, the only conversations taking place on campus about local government and community presence revolve around land use (universities use a lot of land) or workforce development (universities employ a lot of people). But by reimagining these institutions as team members addressing common priorities, MetroLab has kickstarted an entirely new conversation.
SPR: What do you see as the most significant barriers to this interface, and how does your work at MetroLab work to bring about a closer relationship?
KB: There are three recognizable points of friction: bureaucratic, practical, and political.
First, the bureaucratic. On both sides, there’s a deep-dyed brand: The grass is more bureaucratic on the other side of the road. Universities envision cities as rigid hierarchies of slow-moving parts, and cities picture universities as labyrinths of provosts, chancellors, deans, and presidents—enter only if you dare.
There’s also a practical chokepoint. Universities and cities come into the game with different motivations. In a university, motivations include learning opportunities for students or research funding; in a local government, motivations center around an urgency to improve your constituents’ lives. These goals might not seem to be in direct tension, but they operate very differently in practice. Timelines are different, for one. With research, there’s very good reason to be deliberate and methodical, which takes time. But government is impatient. It demands information yesterday to make decisions today. When an academic says, "I want to work on this priority question, and it will take three years," that’s bad news to a city—they’re probably thinking, "that’s most of my administration." Things get lost in translation as well. If a university says, "We’re going to pilot a project," that usually means they will try it for the first time. But to a city, it has a very practical meaning: The project can only cost a specific dollar amount and can take up to some standard amount of time.
The last barrier is political. Based on the research and the science, something might be a very good idea, but people just don’t want it. A study can show bike lanes will improve your economy and eliminate congestion with 95% confidence, but if people hate bike lanes, it’s dead on arrival.
At the mayor’s office in Kansas City, I wrote the ordinance for short-term rentals through Airbnb and VRBO (1). I looked at all of the statistics—impacts to the housing market, dips in frivolous criminal behavior—and they seemed extremely promising. But the majority of the calls that we got from city residents had nothing to do with the numbers. Most of the comments went something like, "I just don’t want it here." Here is where something like MetroLab can help communicate the benefits well, so your community understands the data-driven perspective you do. It took me a long time to realize, with my academic, logical brain that this is worthy of a bullet point.
SPR: How did you arrive at the work you’re doing now?
KB: I got a journalism degree from the University of Kansas in 2008, walked out, and the economy was preparing to fall apart. I was fortunate to end up in the law department of an engineering firm and stayed for about five and a half years. There, I saw how legal deals came together for big infrastructure projects and was absolutely fascinated by it. I left to go to law school, and I immediately knew I wanted to work in local government. I felt so strongly about how substantial life improvements could happen at the regional level, yet local governments were somehow allocated far fewer resources than other levels of government.
I went to law school in Kansas City, Missouri, and started working for the mayor as an intern in my first year. That same year, Uber came. It was a serious departure from the laws that local governments customarily write. It wasn’t a highly regulated industry like taxis or hotels, yet it was already out to the consumer in most places, so people liked it before we could regulate it. I wrote my memo on Uber, fell in love with the job, and never left. I joined as a full-time staff member for the mayor of Kansas City, Sly James, and worked on governance for emerging data-gathering technology like public Wi-Fi [3]. The mayor used to say, "Our laws need to be as innovative as the technology we’re putting on our streets." That was my job. Then, I went to work for the mayor of Seattle, Washington, Jenny Durkan, helping create an Innovation Advisory Council with 17 companies like Amazon, Microsoft, Tableau, and Expedia that did in-kind projects for the city [4].
My working theory on why local government gets the short end of the stick is that it’s hard to see where local government ends and your state or the federal government begins. I think of it like a car: The federal government regulates the general safety of all U.S. vehicles, states step in to manage licensing and highways, and cities run point on parking spots and other boulevards. But how often do you get told who does what? Too often, local governments don’t get the credit they’re due, and their budgets suffer for it.
It’s easier to incentivize excellent work at the local level when you get budgets that supply what you need to perform that work, so you’ve got to be good at telling your story. In Kansas City, a perfect example is our resident satisfaction survey [5]. Thousands of people have responded to it over the years, and they’ve made it clear that their number one frustration is crumbling infrastructure. At every party I went to, people would tell me 1) their name and 2) that there were potholes in their streets that needed fixing. In 2017, we took that story to call for an infusion of money and passed a USD$800 million bond [6].
SPR: Why should academics be interested in contributing to local policymaking?
KB: It is not obvious why an academic would be interested in contributing to local policymaking, but there are a couple of big reasons. First, you’re re-testing your hypothesis out in the community. If you feel you have a working intervention design, it should ideally take flight in nature’s laboratory and, in turn, inform and improve your academic work. In many ways, a city partnership enhances your scientific output.
Secondly, MetroLab talked to academics and asked, "What is one myth you want to bust to the other side of local government?" Time and time again, academics wanted to do away with the fiction that they work in an ivory tower and simply want to research for research’s sake. There are a lot of folks in academia whose mission is to make a difference in people’s lives. We owe it to them to create a better pipeline for research to land someplace it can be actionable. Vice versa, we owe it to our public servants, who oftentimes don’t have the means or capacity to understand the latest problems. MetroLab’s theory of change is that transformational partnerships catalyze innovation. Together, we move faster than in isolation.
SPR: Academia often doesn’t reward civic engagement. How can academics be incentivized to participate in policy work?
KB: Our universities are still the standard-bearers of American research and scientific progress. Private scientific advancement is blooming, but it’s still not at the level that universities are. So the university must be the seeding ground for change.
If academics stay theoretical, it will delay research that could impact our communities. But there’s been a lot of movement recently to make community partnership a prime consideration for academics. The National Science Foundation is baking requirements for community partners into research dollars and grants. This is how systems-level change happens—when the traditional motivations for folks (the money trail or tenure) begin to align with values like civic engagement. Otherwise, individual actors are doing things out of their own kindness.
It takes a village—and more. Journals must prioritize studies with real-world applications. Students should be required to take interdisciplinary or practical, out-of-the-classroom courses. It’s often said on both sides, "You need to get out of the building." Get out of city halls, off campuses, and into communities. This is still a new muscle that academics are building. We have figured out how to put someone on the moon but have not figured out how to end homelessness and poverty. And that is because humans are complicated. You have to get into the community to begin that understanding.
SPR: How can citizens incentivize science policy cross-pollination to happen in their local government?
KB: Vote for budgets that support it. San Antonio is an exemplar. Local universities can develop per-project agreements (under a certain financial threshold) and get fast-tracked through the city council’s approval process. Lane County in Oregon has a similar policy agreement, with funding from the county heading straight to the university.
SPR: What is your vision for successfully integrating research and policy? Are you hopeful, and if so, why?
KB: No one has asked me that question, and it’s a good one.
We have recently seen swift and organized movement among local governments toward hiring chief innovation officers. It has been great. It has challenged a lot of decade-old processes and systems. But at this moment, the need is slightly different. We need the spirit of innovation owned across multiple departments and leaders. The word "innovation" should be invoked less in attempts to stick widgets onto polls and more in steps to bring research into city halls to inform policy and improve services to people. When I began my career in the smart city space, people were thinking very technically—people had big dreams of environmental sensors and electric vehicles buzzing around. A lot of that was driven by the private sector. The AT&T’s and Verizon’s of the world were motivated to do that stuff, and for obvious reasons. But what’s happening now is the truly impactful stuff: innovation for affordable housing, innovation for privacy rights.
Local governments must consider research as something they can procure from universities like they do the concrete on their streets. They should be unafraid to ask difficult questions and demand good answers: e.g., "Why is affordable housing so expensive in my city? I have X dollars to fund it. Don’t give me a 50-page white paper where you provide me unfunded mandates. You get bonus points if you provide me with a partnership structure on how I go about it." Boom, you have created an industry in which science and research have a pipeline straight to a local government.
I’m super optimistic. At MetroLab, our North Star is to forever change the relationship between universities and cities. We’re already seeing things move and shake in places as diverse as San Antonio, Austin, Boston, and South Bend, Indiana. Metro Lab asks local governments, "If you could get research on anything, what would you want?" We change the dialogue. Because at the end of the day, that’s why we’re here. MetroLab wants to be a good-faith partner that makes a real difference in our cities, and we’re well on our way.
